Tuesday, 3 July 2012

AIR RIFLE or RIMFIRE?


The Shooting Show: sub-12ft/lb .177 Air Wolf v rimfire .17HMR 

It's often a question I'm asked - which is best: rimfire or air rifle? It's usually followed by a further question, relating to the air rifle: sub-12ft/lb or FAC-rated?


There's probably no 'right' answer - each has their merits as explained in the video shot for TheShootingShow channel on YouTube, where I was invited along to shoot rabbits with my 11ft/lb .177 calibre Air Wolf alongside a .17HMR pest controller on his patch of land.


In the (fairly short) time we each had, the score was 2-2 - though I picked up both my bunnies, and Mark, the .17 shooter, only one as he unfortunately had a 'runner'.


The grass was very long, and there was a strong breeze, so even though I had a great vantage point on top of the 4x4, I chose to limit my range. As tempting as the bunnies were at 50 yards, off a bipod, the land was alien to me and the conditions just added that little bit too much of a risk. My rabbits were therefore taken at 38 and 43 yards (I used a laser rangefinder to mark points beforehand).


Mark took his rabbits around 20 yards further on - and could easily have stretched that range further if it wasn't for the stems of the long grass blowing about in the breeze.


We shooters agreed that for out-and-out pest control, the rimfire probably had the advantage - but Mark (who hasn't shot an air rifle in years) was suitably impressed with the air rifle's capability... and the fact that it was so accurate even in the wind on 40 yarders. Plus, of course, this head-to-head finished even-stevens.


That said, we were both minced by the 'third' competitor in the challenge - long nets!


Watch the full video here.

4 comments:

  1. wow!!
    it awesome air guns for hunting. Thanks for sharing this.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dear Nigel, I'm writting here because I couldn't get hold of your email.
    I watched almost all your videos and want to buy a PCP air rifle.
    I live in Lebanon and after quite some search, I found out that we have 3 PCP s available. The Slavia (650USD), Crosman Marauder (950USD will be available mid August) and the Diana P1000 (around 1500USD Will be available mid August.
    Any advise which one to buy, I'm interested in the .22 and I have read a lot of revies on all gun types and it is getting confusing.
    Kindly advise, BR Saleh

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Nigel,i personally wouldnt use a daystate for hunting due to its lack of power compared to a hw100s. maybe u could throw some light on the problem with daystate suplying rifles that are lucky to get above 10.5 ft with jsb 4.52 8.4 grain. I have never come across such poor after service.It was returned to daystate for low power when it came back it was still the same and cost me 50 pounds. tested on several cronos lucky to get 10.5. the gun is only good for plinking .waste of money. ps use a rimfire with a silencer 24x scope shoot to 60 meter. airguns are for targets not for hunting.

    ReplyDelete
  4. steyr.in first online shop for Germany made Air Rifles and Air Pistols and Air Guns in India
    sports air pistol
    Air guns

    ReplyDelete